Local Music Reviews
Debra Fotheringham
Valley of Annihilation
Groundloop Records
Street 10.24.2025
Debra Fotheringham = Hayley Williams + Dido
Debra Fotheringham’s Valley of Annihilation is good. It’s damn good. If you’re one of those folks that briefly skims these reviews, there’s your bottom line — now piss off and listen to it!
For those of you who enjoy foreplay before the main event, the background story is what made all the various moving parts of this album fall into place for me; it’s also what made it so absolutely gut wrenching to listen to.
It goes like this: Fotheringham and her husband of 15 years are smothered by the crushing weight of COVID panic and chaos as it settles into Utah Valley in the early days. They don’t like it. They book it to the remote woods of Vermont seeking some reprieve, all the while thinking they are running away from their problems and toward a new, wonderful life together. Instead, the forced isolation creates an idyllic environment for self-reflection and a mutual identity shift that culminates into the heartbreaking dissolution of their marriage. Fotheringham takes all of this in, returns to Utah to completely rebuild her life — to some, exciting; to me, scary as fuck — and then proceeds to coherently metabolize everything she’s experienced into this brilliant body of work.
Fotheringham recorded Valley of Annihilation at June Audio in Provo, and it certainly meets that expected quality. In the spirit of new beginnings and self-reflection, the record is also generally polyamorous with regard to genre, serving up a steamy dish of pop with a few smidgens of soul and rock and the occasional folk and bluegrass morsel. This, in my opinion, made the record more cohesive, providing a much more interesting ride from start to finish.
There were several songs that got the aggressively underlined “beautiful” next to the track name on my yellow legal pad, the first of which being “Ebb & Flow,” my undisputed favorite song on the record. This song is Fotheringham’s “Clay Pigeons” or “Sunday Morning Coming Down.” It isn’t hyperbole for me to say that I truly wish I had written this. The song has a timeless feel and a stripped-back nylon arrangement, largely just Fotheringham and her guitar. The protagonist wanders the world alone as, (ironically) contrary to what her internal dialogue is telling her, the world stays on the move around her. She’s lost in thought, wondering, “Will I always ebb and flow?” Fotheringham reflects on the self-doubt that haunts her, the voice at times saying, “I’ll never be enough.” In a constant state of emotional transience, she realizes she’s losing the one she once loved, but we see the friction: “You don’t need to hold me still, I just need you to hold me.”
Another favorite of mine is “Rosy View,” a song with a much fuller card of instrumental arrangement than “Ebb and Flow.” The synth, in particular, gets me all riled up on this one. As the title suggests, the song explores a feeling of “chronic malcontent” toward, assuming what we know with backstory, the artist’s relationship: “You disappointed me, I disappointed you, I’m never satisfied / moved from west to east to leave my sunset heart behind.” The song explores that moment in a relationship where it’s clear that shit isn’t right and likely won’t be fixed. Do we shift our perspective and put on a pair of spectacles to try to change the lighting, or do we mail it in and call it a day? Absolutely heartbreaking.
The final song that had me wanting to refill the wine glass was “Hibernation,” the last song on the track list. It begins with a Hozier-esque, Celtic-influenced guitar arrangement and melody. This is the resolution to the chapter: “Comin’ out of hibernation, feelin’ all these new sensations, letting go of the frustration.” Fotheringham paints a brand-new day; she’s finally made it to spring, and the feeling of the sun on her face like it’s the first time. This song feels like it was written on the other side of the stages of grief, where forgiveness can finally trickle in: “I’m supposed to resent you, and sometimes I still do, but mostly I just love you.” Such a wonderful way to put the final touches on a breakup, but Fotheringham isn’t done yet, saving her best for last: “I’m not afraid to feel it all, the pain of losing you and my role in the fall / the mystery of life’s end and the fucking breathless beauty of it all.”
Valley of Annihilation was produced by Scott Wiley and was released into the world on Groundloop Records. It’s available to stream just about everywhere, but luckily for all you vinyl-heads, it also looks like it can be purchased as a physical copy. —Cole Stocker
Read more local music reviews by Cole Stocker:
Local Review: Alli Brown — Undeniable
Local Review: Nicky V A and the Four Locos — The Pinto Lounge for Broken Hearts
Want to help SLUG continue highlighting local musicians? Consider joining our community of donors!
